Your verdict
Your page is mostly the same.
Most of what your page says, Discovery Insure says too. You're less same than 4 of the 48 services sites scored (services avg 59).
Each named site is scored the same way, against the other 4 in this set, so its tick means the same as your marker. The dashed line is the frozen benchmark average.
More same than average
The average services site scores 59; you scored 70.
You are 11 points more same than the average services site.
Closest overlap: Discovery Insure
Of the 4 sites you named, Discovery Insure echoes the most of what your page says: 88% of it, weighted by placement. Scored the same way you were, against the rest of the set, Discovery Insure's own Sameness Index is 57. Those are different measures: the first is overlap with your page, the second is how same Discovery Insure's whole page is.
Discovery Insure is the competitor you sound most like.
Room to own more
10% of your claim space is ownable: unique, relevant, and hard to copy. 3 of those claims sit in body copy, where few readers reach them.
10% is ownable, and 3 buried opportunities could help you stand out more.
Three changes worth testing first.
Chosen by rule from the comparison with Discovery Insure, OUTsurance and Santam: the shared claim taking your most prominent space, then the claims only you make that sit too low on the page to be read. Each one links to its claim card.
- “CALL ME”
Discovery Insure, OUTsurance and Santam all say it too. Buyers may still need it, but shared ground cannot carry your hero — move it lower and give that space to something only you can say.
Table stakesMost of the set says this too. - “This covers you for fire, theft and hi-jacking. It also covers you for damage to other people's property due to a car accident you're involved in.”
Nobody in the set says this. It sits in body copy, where few readers reach it — worth testing higher up the page; only buyers can tell you whether it lands.
SurfaceYours alone. Test it higher up. - “This covers you for accidental damage you cause to other people's property as the result of a car accident.”
A claim that is yours alone, filed in body copy. Try it where it will be read before the shared claims are, and let buyers tell you if it moves them.
SurfaceYours alone. Test it higher up.
Try these changes, then test them with real buyers.
This measures overlap. Whether buyers notice is a different question, and only they can answer it.
What you can own
Claims only you make, that buyers weigh, and that competitors can’t easily copy.
10% of your page’s claim space is yours to keep.
Why this is not 100 minus the Sameness Index
The index is a weighted composite across six categories, including page structure and visuals. This bar is measured on your claims alone, weighted by where each one sits on the page. Different denominators, so the two never add to 100 and are not meant to.
Already leading with · 1
- Premium decreases monthly with car value
“We're the only insurer to offer premiums that decrease monthly as your car loses value.”
Buried in body copy · 3
- Third party, fire and theft cover
“This covers you for fire, theft and hi-jacking. It also covers you for damage to other people's property due to a car accident you're involved in.”
- Third-party-only cover
“This covers you for accidental damage you cause to other people's property as the result of a car accident.”
- Total-loss-only cover option
“This covers you for the total loss of your car, like if it's written-off, or if it's stolen or hi-jacked and not recovered.”
Where you blend in
Territory you spend prominent space on that the set also occupies. Not every line is one to delete — the question is whether it has earned the space, or whether something only you can say should be there instead.
- Commodity · 100%Table stakesHeroAccess to a human advisor
- “CALL ME”
Discovery Insure, OUTsurance and Santam all cover this territory. Buyers may need to hear it, but in your hero it spends the first impression on shared ground.
They say- Discovery Insure“dedicated Discovery Insure executive consultant and exclusive experiences”
- OUTsurance“Capture details online, and an advisor will phone you back with your premium.”
- OUTsurance“Capture details online, and an advisor will phone you back with your premium.”
- Santam“An authorised Santam adviser will contact you within 24 business hours”
- Commodity · 75%Table stakesHeroFair, competitive pricing
- “It's the fair and logical way insurance should be done!”
Common ground with Discovery Insure, OUTsurance and Santam. Say it if buyers need it — lower on the page, where it is not the thing they read first. Nobody else uses your exact words, but everyone is on the ground. Nobody else makes this exact claim, but everyone occupies the territory — lead with the specific, not the generic.
They say- Discovery Insure“innovative features, award-winning safety features and exceptional service at competitive rates”
- OUTsurance“Looking for affordable insurance for an older car?”
- Santam“Core: Most affordable”
- Commodity · 75%Table stakesHeroPremium adjusts to your car or driving
- “We're the only insurer to offer premiums that decrease monthly as your car loses value.”
Discovery Insure, OUTsurance and Santam make the same claim (75% of the set). It cannot set you apart, so it should not carry the hero. Nobody else uses your exact words, but everyone is on the ground. Nobody else makes this exact claim, but everyone occupies the territory — lead with the specific, not the generic.
They say- Discovery Insure“Discovery car Insurance plans start from R499 per month. Premiums are personalised and based on your profile, cover requirements and risk assessment”
- OUTsurance“Get a quote from OUTsurance to receive a premium tailored to your specific circumstances.”
- Santam“With SmartPark™, you can save up to 20% on your premium if you drive less than 15,000 km a year”
- Commodity · 75%Table stakesHeroQuote and manage policy online
- “GET A QUOTE ONLINE”
A buyer comparing tabs sees this on Discovery Insure, OUTsurance and Santam too (75% of the set). Yours earns nothing by repeating it up top; it can live lower down.
They say- Discovery Insure“Get a car insurance quote in 60 seconds”
- OUTsurance“Log in or use our App to manage your policy; view and manage your policy”
- Santam“Santam's digital platform lets you compare vehicle insurance quotes and customise your cover to match your needs”
- Commodity · 100%Table stakesSectionDefined claim payout and repair terms
- “With agreed value, the insured value noted on your policy schedule is the amount the car is covered for, for 3 years.”
Discovery Insure, OUTsurance and Santam got here first as far as a buyer can tell. Keep the fact for readers who need it; move the position to a claim only your page can make. Nobody else uses your exact words, but everyone is on the ground. Nobody else makes this exact claim, but everyone occupies the territory — lead with the specific, not the generic.
They say- Discovery Insure“Replacement value of new car of similar make and model if the car is less than 24-months old”
- OUTsurance“Your vehicle will be repaired by one of our approved service providers and your repairs are guaranteed for a 12-month period.”
- OUTsurance“Theft cover: if your car is stolen or hijacked, we pay you the full retail value, minus a standard R3 370 first amount not covered.”
- Santam“Santam has an accredited network of trusted repairers to ensure quality and guarantee workmanship”
- Commodity · 100%KeepSectionPlans tiered by life stage and budget
- “an option for every need and budget”
Discovery Insure, OUTsurance and Santam all say what they are and who they are for, as every page in a category must. Keep it — it is orientation, not differentiation.
They say- Discovery Insure“Core Plan: budget-friendly plan for those building their financial foundation”
- OUTsurance“Compare Comprehensive and Essential Car Insurance side by side to find the cover that best fits your needs and budget.”
- OUTsurance“Compare Comprehensive and Essential Car Insurance to find the option that best suits your needs, budget and vehicle.”
- Santam“We offer three flexible options, each designed to match your financial stage and insurance needs”
- Commodity · 75%Table stakesSectionOptional add-on cover extras
- “Looking to add some additional cover to your policy? Here's a list of what you could add for extra peace of mind.”
Discovery Insure, OUTsurance and Santam make the same claim (75% of the set). It cannot set you apart, so it should not carry the section.
They say- Discovery Insure“Locks and keys cover for loss of or damage to keys, locks and remote-control units”
- OUTsurance“Your vehicle's standard factory-fitted sound equipment is automatically covered, with optional cover for additional sound gear.”
- Santam“Enhance your car insurance policy with optional add-ons tailored to your lifestyle, vehicle, and budget”
- Commodity · 75%Table stakesSectionRange of cover types to choose from
- “From comprehensive car insurance, to third party only insurance, we've got an option for every need and budget out there.”
Shared with Discovery Insure, OUTsurance and Santam, 75% of the set. True of you, true of them — which is exactly why it will not decide anything.
They say- Discovery Insure“Comprehensive covers loss or damage from theft, hijacking, hail, storm, fire, lightning, explosion and malicious or accidental damage”
- OUTsurance“Cover against loss or damage caused by theft, hijacking, accidents, flood, hail and even intentional damage caused by someone else.”
- Santam“Santam offers a range of car insurance options to suit your needs, whether comprehensive, third-party only, or something in between”
- Contested · 50%SharpenSectionEarn discounts or cashback, lowering cost
- “Get up to 20% off when you insure multiple cars”
Discovery Insure and OUTsurance are on this territory too (50% of the set). It narrows the field without winning it — make it specific enough that it cannot be said of them.
They say- Discovery Insure“Multi-vehicle benefit reduces your premiums if you own several cars, but only one is driven at a time”
- OUTsurance“OUTbonus: You'll get 10% of your paid premiums back in cash after three claim-free years.”
Claim-by-claim evidence
Every claim on your page (23)
What the columns mean
- Claim
- The grouped claim, then your exact line beneath it.
- Type
- What kind of claim it is: category, segment, outcome, capability, quality or proof.
- Placement
- Where it sits on your page: hero, section or body copy. Hero claims weigh most in the index.
- Same claim
- Share of the competitors making this exact claim. Drives ownership and ownable share.
- Same territory
- Share of the competitors with any claim in the same buyer-facing territory. This is what the index is scored on.
- Sayability
- Whether a competitor could truthfully make the same claim: anyone could, copyable with effort, or hard to copy.
- Relevant
- Whether buyers decide on this. A unique claim nobody buys on is not ownable.
- Ownership
- Commodity: 60% or more of the set says it. Contested: 20–59%. Unique: under 20%, owned when it is also hard to copy.
Tap a column to sort by it; tap again to reverse. Sorted by Same claim, highest first.
Request an advisor callback “CALL ME” | capability | Hero | 75% | 100% | Anyone could say it | No | Commodity |
Options to fit every need and budget “an option for every need and budget” | segment | Section | 75% | 100% | Anyone could say it | Yes | Commodity |
Car hire after a claim “Car hire” | capability | Body | 75% | 75% | Anyone could say it | Yes | Commodity |
Credit shortfall gap cover “Credit shortfall” | capability | Body | 50% | 75% | Anyone could say it | Yes | Contested |
Premium personalised to your risk profile “Premiums are risk profile-dependent and reviewed annually.” | capability | Body | 50% | 75% | Anyone could say it | Yes | Contested |
Get and compare quotes online “GET A QUOTE ONLINE” | capability | Hero | 25% | 75% | Anyone could say it | Yes | Contested |
Discount for insuring multiple cars “Get up to 20% off when you insure multiple cars” | outcome | Section | 25% | 50% | Anyone could say it | Yes | Contested |
Optional add-ons to extend cover “Looking to add some additional cover to your policy? Here's a list of what you could add for extra peace of mind.” | capability | Section | 25% | 75% | Anyone could say it | Yes | Contested |
Range from comprehensive to third-party cover “From comprehensive car insurance, to third party only insurance, we've got an option for every need and budget out there.” | capability | Section | 25% | 75% | Anyone could say it | Yes | Contested |
Car sound equipment cover “Specified radio” | capability | Body | 25% | 75% | Anyone could say it | No | Contested |
Chauffeur drive-home service “King's cab” | capability | Body | 25% | 75% | Anyone could say it | No | Contested |
Classic and collectable car cover “Collectable car insurance insures your classic or high-value car against accident damage, theft, hi-jacking, and damage to other people's property.” | segment | Body | 25% | 25% | Anyone could say it | Yes | Contested |
Driving less lowers your premium “This works on a 'pay per k' basis, so the less you drive, the less you pay!” | capability | Body | 25% | 75% | Anyone could say it | Yes | Contested |
Tyre and rim damage cover “Tyre and rim” | capability | Body | 25% | 75% | Anyone could say it | No | Contested |
Insurance done fairly and logically “It's the fair and logical way insurance should be done!” | quality | Hero | 0% | 75% | Anyone could say it | No | Unique for now |
Premium decreases monthly with car value “We're the only insurer to offer premiums that decrease monthly as your car loses value.” | capability | Hero | 0% | 75% | Copyable with effort | Yes | Unique and owned |
Agreed value cover for 3 years “With agreed value, the insured value noted on your policy schedule is the amount the car is covered for, for 3 years.” | capability | Section | 0% | 100% | Anyone could say it | Yes | Unique for now |
R1 insurance add-on “R1 insurance” | capability | Body | 0% | 75% | Anyone could say it | No | Unique for now |
Scratch and dent cover “Scratch and dent” | capability | Body | 0% | 75% | Anyone could say it | No | Unique for now |
Small dings and tyre cover “Little dings and tyre things” | capability | Body | 0% | 75% | Anyone could say it | No | Unique for now |
Third party, fire and theft cover “This covers you for fire, theft and hi-jacking. It also covers you for damage to other people's property due to a car accident you're involved in.” | capability | Body | 0% | 75% | Anyone could say it | Yes | Unique for now |
Third-party-only cover “This covers you for accidental damage you cause to other people's property as the result of a car accident.” | capability | Body | 0% | 75% | Anyone could say it | Yes | Unique for now |
Total-loss-only cover option “This covers you for the total loss of your car, like if it's written-off, or if it's stolen or hi-jacked and not recovered.” | capability | Body | 0% | 75% | Anyone could say it | Yes | Unique for now |
- Request an advisor callback“CALL ME”capabilityHerosame claim 75%same territory 100%Anyone could say itnot a buying criterionCommodityAlso on OUTsurance, OUTsurance, Santam
- Options to fit every need and budget“an option for every need and budget”segmentSectionsame claim 75%same territory 100%Anyone could say itCommodityAlso on OUTsurance, OUTsurance, Santam
- Car hire after a claim“Car hire”capabilityBodysame claim 75%same territory 75%Anyone could say itCommodityAlso on Discovery Insure, OUTsurance, Santam
- Credit shortfall gap cover“Credit shortfall”capabilityBodysame claim 50%same territory 75%Anyone could say itContestedAlso on OUTsurance, Santam
- Premium personalised to your risk profile“Premiums are risk profile-dependent and reviewed annually.”capabilityBodysame claim 50%same territory 75%Anyone could say itContestedAlso on Discovery Insure, OUTsurance
- Get and compare quotes online“GET A QUOTE ONLINE”capabilityHerosame claim 25%same territory 75%Anyone could say itContestedAlso on Santam
- Discount for insuring multiple cars“Get up to 20% off when you insure multiple cars”outcomeSectionsame claim 25%same territory 50%Anyone could say itContestedAlso on Discovery Insure
- Optional add-ons to extend cover“Looking to add some additional cover to your policy? Here's a list of what you could add for extra peace of mind.”capabilitySectionsame claim 25%same territory 75%Anyone could say itContestedAlso on Santam
- Range from comprehensive to third-party cover“From comprehensive car insurance, to third party only insurance, we've got an option for every need and budget out there.”capabilitySectionsame claim 25%same territory 75%Anyone could say itContestedAlso on Santam
- Car sound equipment cover“Specified radio”capabilityBodysame claim 25%same territory 75%Anyone could say itnot a buying criterionContestedAlso on OUTsurance
- Chauffeur drive-home service“King's cab”capabilityBodysame claim 25%same territory 75%Anyone could say itnot a buying criterionContestedAlso on Santam
- Classic and collectable car cover“Collectable car insurance insures your classic or high-value car against accident damage, theft, hi-jacking, and damage to other people's property.”segmentBodysame claim 25%same territory 25%Anyone could say itContestedAlso on Santam
- Driving less lowers your premium“This works on a 'pay per k' basis, so the less you drive, the less you pay!”capabilityBodysame claim 25%same territory 75%Anyone could say itContestedAlso on Santam
- Tyre and rim damage cover“Tyre and rim”capabilityBodysame claim 25%same territory 75%Anyone could say itnot a buying criterionContestedAlso on Santam
- Insurance done fairly and logically“It's the fair and logical way insurance should be done!”qualityHerosame claim 0%same territory 75%Anyone could say itnot a buying criterionUnique for now
- Premium decreases monthly with car value“We're the only insurer to offer premiums that decrease monthly as your car loses value.”capabilityHerosame claim 0%same territory 75%Copyable with effortUnique and owned
- Agreed value cover for 3 years“With agreed value, the insured value noted on your policy schedule is the amount the car is covered for, for 3 years.”capabilitySectionsame claim 0%same territory 100%Anyone could say itUnique for now
- R1 insurance add-on“R1 insurance”capabilityBodysame claim 0%same territory 75%Anyone could say itnot a buying criterionUnique for now
- Scratch and dent cover“Scratch and dent”capabilityBodysame claim 0%same territory 75%Anyone could say itnot a buying criterionUnique for now
- Small dings and tyre cover“Little dings and tyre things”capabilityBodysame claim 0%same territory 75%Anyone could say itnot a buying criterionUnique for now
- Third party, fire and theft cover“This covers you for fire, theft and hi-jacking. It also covers you for damage to other people's property due to a car accident you're involved in.”capabilityBodysame claim 0%same territory 75%Anyone could say itUnique for now
- Third-party-only cover“This covers you for accidental damage you cause to other people's property as the result of a car accident.”capabilityBodysame claim 0%same territory 75%Anyone could say itUnique for now
- Total-loss-only cover option“This covers you for the total loss of your car, like if it's written-off, or if it's stolen or hi-jacked and not recovered.”capabilityBodysame claim 0%same territory 75%Anyone could say itUnique for now
How this was calculated
Sameness measures how much your claims overlap with the sites compared. It does not measure message quality or whether buyers prefer you.
AI-analyzed: an AI read each page on its own and grouped the claims that say the same thing. No score here was written by a model — every number is computed from those groupings in our own code, with the weights below.
How the score is built
| Category | Weight | Yours | What a high score means |
|---|---|---|---|
Messaging Category framing, who it is for, and the outcome promised | 30% | 68 | The most expensive kind of sameness. A buyer cannot tell what job you do that the others do not. |
Claims Attribute and benefit claims — speed, ease, quality, ROI | 30% | 75 | Every shared claim is a line already read on another tab. Cut the ones nobody owns and spend the space on something they cannot. |
Features Capabilities and functions the page lists | 15% | 80 | Expected in a mature category, and the least alarming of the six. Feature parity is normal; leading with it is the mistake. |
Proof The kinds of evidence offered: customer logos, numbers, testimonials, case studies, badges | 10% | n/a | Same kinds of proof as everyone means the proof stops working as proof. It is scored on the kind of evidence, not on which customers are named. |
Structure Section order, navigation, CTA language and placement | 10% | 56 | The generic SaaS template — hero, logos, three-feature grid, testimonial, CTA. Familiar is not the same as memorable. |
Visual Palette family, imagery style, layout patterns | 5% | 59 | Weighted lowest on purpose: buyers rarely decide on this. Worth knowing, rarely worth fixing first. |
Each site was read on its own first, with no knowledge of the others, so your page gets no benefit of the doubt a competitor’s does not. A category nothing could be measured for drops out and the rest are re-weighted, rather than counted as zero.
What we compared (5 pages read)
What it cannot tell you
The index can find where two pages converge. It cannot say whether a buyer would notice, or which of your reasons to buy actually land. A single check also moves several points between runs, so read the band and the ranking, not the last digit.
Your highest-impact changes
- 1Table stakesYour hero copy says “CALL ME”.
Discovery Insure, OUTsurance and Santam all say it too. Buyers may still need it, but shared ground cannot carry your hero — move it lower and give that space to something only you can say.
- 2Table stakesYour hero copy says “GET A QUOTE ONLINE”.
Keep the fact, lose the position: discovery Insure, OUTsurance and Santam say it too (75% of the set), and your hero is spending its first impression on the same territory as theirs.
- 3Table stakesYour hero copy says “It's the fair and logical way insurance should be done!”.
This is the set's common ground — Discovery Insure, OUTsurance and Santam say it too (75% of the set). It will not set you apart wherever it sits, and in the hero it costs you the one place a distinctive claim would be read.
- 4Table stakesYour hero copy says “We're the only insurer to offer premiums that decrease monthly as your car loses value.”.
A buyer with three tabs open reads a version of this on every one of them. Say it further down for the readers who need it; the hero should carry a claim they will only find here.
- 5Table stakesYour section copy says “With agreed value, the insured value noted on your policy schedule is the amount the car is covered for, for…”.
True of you and true of them: Discovery Insure, OUTsurance and Santam all say it too. That is why it decides nothing, and why the section is the wrong place to spend it.
- 6Table stakesYour section copy says “an option for every need and budget”.
In the section: Keep the fact, lose the position: discovery Insure, OUTsurance and Santam all say it too, and your section is spending its first impression on the same territory as theirs.
- 7Table stakesYour section copy says “Looking to add some additional cover to your policy? Here's a list of what you could add for extra peace of m…”.
In the section: Discovery Insure, OUTsurance and Santam say it too (75% of the set). Buyers may still need it, but shared ground cannot carry your section — move it lower and give that space to something only you can say.
- 8Table stakesYour section copy says “From comprehensive car insurance, to third party only insurance, we've got an option for every need and budge…”.
In the section: True of you and true of them: Discovery Insure, OUTsurance and Santam say it too (75% of the set). That is why it decides nothing, and why the section is the wrong place to spend it.
- 9Surface“This covers you for fire, theft and hi-jacking. It also covers you for damage to other people's property due…” is yours alone, and buyers weigh it.
Nobody in the set says this. It sits in body copy, where few readers reach it — worth testing higher up the page; only buyers can tell you whether it lands.
- 10Surface“This covers you for accidental damage you cause to other people's property as the result of a car accident.” is yours alone, and buyers weigh it.
A claim that is yours alone, filed in body copy. Try it where it will be read before the shared claims are, and let buyers tell you if it moves them.
- 11Surface“This covers you for the total loss of your car, like if it's written-off, or if it's stolen or hi-jacked and…” is yours alone, and buyers weigh it.
No competitor page makes this claim. Today it is in body copy; it is a candidate for the space the table-stakes lines are taking.
The only way to know if it matters.
This report can tell you where your messaging overlaps. It cannot tell you whether a buyer would care, or which of your reasons to buy actually land. Put the page in front of real B2B buyers in your target market and ask them.







